Middle Island Country Club

Middle Island Country Club stands as the centerpiece of public golf on Long Island, offering 27 holes of championship golf that challenge the best while rewarding patient play and rarely play the same way twice. Nestled in Middle Island, New York, the course sits at 275 Yaphank Middle Island Rd (ZIP 11953), a central hub for golfers across the island seeking a varied, engaging round. Carved from 225 acres of the historic Lustengarten Nursery, the property blends mature, natural beauty with a fair yet competitive layout. The three 9-hole layouts deliver different angles on a par 36, totaling 3234 yards with a slope of 126 and a rating of 71.6. Built in 1963, Middle Island’s contours test accuracy and strategy, from tight approaches to wider fairways that reward thoughtful shot placement. Unique features include the preserved nursery-era landscape, crisp greens, and a respectful balance between playability and challenge. Ideal for public-golf seekers on Long Island, it’s conveniently located in the heart of the island. Book your round with GolfWithBrio and discover why this course remains a local favorite.